Skip to main content
Legal news

Builder fined after client breaks spine in fall

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
1 min read

A builder who left a staircase in a dangerous state has been fined at Sheffield Magistrates Court after his client fell and broke his spine.

The court heard that Michael Hall was lucky to be alive after the fall which took place at his house in Sheffield where a new staircase had been installed. However the work was not completed and it had been left without a handrail and Mr Hall fell 10ft, breaking his spine and suffering broken ribs and massive head injuries. He spent time in intensive care and has subsequently had to learn to walk and talk again, though he has made a 90% recovery.

The builder, Robin Atherton, who traded as Mack Construction, reported the incident to the HSE whose inspectors brought the prosecution. Atherton pleaded guilty to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and was fined £5,000 and ordered to pay £4,000 costs.

HSE inspector Medani Close said that Mr Hall was lucky to be alive although his injuries have had a terrible effect on him, his family and his business. She added: “This tragic fall could so easily have been avoided. The simplest of measures – a temporary handrail fitted to the open side of the new staircase in his home – could have prevented his fall and saved a huge amount of suffering.”

Client feedback

Monika made the whole Wil process very simple & was more than happy to explain any concerns we had.
Jane
was a CIACA case, great service, professional, kept informed all the way
Faris
I found Sidraa to be very thorough, proactively raising questions about the conveyance even before I had asked her myself. All communication was clear and regular updates provided, which was very helpful.It was a stressful process (what house move isn’t!)due to an issue dragging on, no fault on the Solicitors’ part but meant exchange and completion in quick succession! Ultimately, Sidraa and Tom worked very hard to achieve the completion date everyone wanted so thank you 🙏
Dorothy
Emily was a very patient and supportive lady, as we were not very clued in to dealing with some of the internet issues and she guided us through it.Emily made altering our wills a breeze, would use this firm Winston solicitors 100 percent for all our business.
Tina
Leasa and the team at Winston solicitors have been really good. Leasa was very thorough in her work helping me with my house purchase. I can highly recommend her and Winston solicitors for conveyancing.
Maria
Winston Solicitors are the best solicitor firm I have dealt with. They helped sell my house. Sidraa and Tom were always communicating with me and turned things round quickly when I was going out of the country. I would definitely use them again and that’s not the case usually with solicitor firms.
Rob
I received a welcoming and efficient service from Monika at Winston’s. A lovely, friendly lady that was very professional at the same time. I would use Winston’s again.
Michelle
Initially the person that was allocated to me was not very good and I didn’t get any compensation but when I changed the person and pushed for review to look at again I was able to get the compensation awarded. It did take time nearly 2 years.
Zara
Contact us