Legal news

Builder fined after client breaks spine in fall

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
1 min read
This blog is more than 14 years old

A builder who left a staircase in a dangerous state has been fined at Sheffield Magistrates Court after his client fell and broke his spine.

The court heard that Michael Hall was lucky to be alive after the fall which took place at his house in Sheffield where a new staircase had been installed. However the work was not completed and it had been left without a handrail and Mr Hall fell 10ft, breaking his spine and suffering broken ribs and massive head injuries. He spent time in intensive care and has subsequently had to learn to walk and talk again, though he has made a 90% recovery.

The builder, Robin Atherton, who traded as Mack Construction, reported the incident to the HSE whose inspectors brought the prosecution. Atherton pleaded guilty to a breach of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and was fined £5,000 and ordered to pay £4,000 costs.

HSE inspector Medani Close said that Mr Hall was lucky to be alive although his injuries have had a terrible effect on him, his family and his business. She added: “This tragic fall could so easily have been avoided. The simplest of measures – a temporary handrail fitted to the open side of the new staircase in his home – could have prevented his fall and saved a huge amount of suffering.”

Client feedback

Fantastic service - super efficient, no nonsense, quick and communicative. I own and run a Leeds-based Estate Agency and we've tried and tested many many conveyancing solicitors and I can honestly say, Winstons (Samantha and team in particular) are amongst the best! Thanks so much for your help with my recent property sale!
Jonathan
I would highly recommend Winston Solicitors! I was referred by my cousin who also had a fantastic experience. I can’t thank Samantha and Joe enough for their services from day one. They made the whole house buying process feel clear and much less daunting, which I particularly appreciated buying on my own for the first time. They were very responsive and went above and beyond to ensure that I completed on the day I had hoped. The attention to detail in the enquiries was particularly appreciated. Thank you!
Megan
Professional and friendly staff. Complete process on time. Quick response for queries.
Sana
Was assisted by Samira Cakali cannot fault her advice one bit. Knew exactly what steps to take to ensure a quick, clean and lucrative exit. I would recommend Winstons Solicitors to anyone seeking advice or action regarding employment law.
Anonymous
Winston’s were easy to engage and provided clear and transparent information on the process and upfront costs. Once engaged they were responsive and simple to work with. In particular Sidraa was excellent to work with, she was quick to respond and helpful. I was very appreciative of the efficiency and pace with which we progressed.
Tom
Excellent service and easy to contact when needed. Professional advice - would recommend!
Craig
I found Winstons to be a highly professional, efficient and compassionate firm of solicitors. The original estimate of fees for dealing with a complex probate matter including the sale of a property and dealing with inheritance tax proved to be very close to the final amount charged. At all stages throughout the process I was kept well informed of progress and was consulted whenever necessary. All correspondence was polite and pertinent, and my wishes were acted upon promptly. I would have no hesitation in recommending Winstons to others and would readily use their services myself in the future should the need arise.
Anonymous
The professional services provided by Winston Solicitors was exemplary. They were very professional and made the experience as pleasant as it could be. I would happily recommend Winston Solicitors.
Louis
Contact us