Skip to main content
Legal news

Naked sleepwalker wins libel case

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read
This blog is more than 15 years old

An Irish businessman has won a libel case against his employer after it claimed that he had made inappropriate advances to a female colleague.

Donal Kinsella sued Kenmare Resources, a mining company based in Dublin, following a press release the firm issued claiming that when on an African business trip in 2007, he had made the advances. Kenmare issued the statement in an attempt to justify its decision to ask Mr Kinsella to step down from his job as chairman of its audit committee. In it they said that “something juicy” had taken place on the business trip, strongly suggesting that his conduct had been inappropriate.

The allegations were that Kinsella had been sleepwalking naked and went to the bedroom door of the firm’s secretary Deidre Corcoran three times, but each time was told to go back to his own bed. The jury at Ireland’s supreme court heard that Kinsella had been drinking and had taken painkillers. However solicitors for the company, after investigating the incident, found that Kinsella had made no attempt to enter Miss Corcoran’s bedroom and there was no evidence of improper conduct.

The supreme court awarded Mr Kinsella €10m in damages, an amount five times bigger than any previous libel case in Ireland. Kenmare Resources has said that it will appeal.

https://www.theguardian.com/law/2010/nov/18/naked-sleepwalker-record-libel-payout

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

Excellent, responsive and professional service
Emma
Monika made writing my Will very easy. Her calm and friendly approach was professional, clear and reassuring. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Winston Solicitors.
Paul
I found Amanda very easy to deal with, she kept me in the loop and informed throughout the process, spoke in a language I understood and didn’t overpromise. She’s very professional, happy to answer questions, always courteous and knowledgeable.
Anika
Excellent job by Michelle with my conveyancing. Clear communication. Rapid responses. Everything you could want.
Graham
Michelle was our conveyancer for our recent house purchase. Her professionalism, thoroughness and quick responses throughout the process made the purchase as easy as possible for us - we are very grateful to her and the rest of the team at Winston Solicitors for their work.
Anonymous
had a great experience with winston solicitor company. The team was professional, friendly, and helpful throughout the whole process. Joe Rawnsley was fantastic. He kept me informed, answered all my questions, and made everything straightforward and stress-free. I’m very happy with the service I received and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy solicitor.
Bijan
They are very quick in replying and clarifying your questions. Also very smooth transaction process overall.
David
I have now used Winston’s for a number of services and highly rate them all round. My most recent experience was of their conveyancing team who have again been helpful from start to finish with the sale of my previous property and new purchase. The new purchase was not straight forward but Winston’s managed this extremely well with even the estate agent noting how helpful they were. I’m very appreciative to Michelle for her all her help with this
Jo
Contact Jonathan