Skip to main content

How to Exercise a Break Clause in a Commercial Lease

Understanding a Break Clause in Commercial Leases

A break clause can give you a valuable opportunity to end a lease early, but serving notice is only part of the process. You need to check the notice requirements and satisfy any conditions within the timescales the lease sets. Getting it right starts months before the break notice date, so it is important to allow time to plan an exit properly.

Our commercial property solicitors advise tenants and landlords on exercising break clauses.

What Is a Break Clause in a Commercial Lease?

A break clause is a term in a lease that lets the landlord or the tenant end the lease before its contractual expiry date. It is a right that exists only on the terms written into the lease.

There are three key points to check.

  1. Who can break. Many breaks are for the tenant only. A landlord's break is often there to allow redevelopment or a sale with vacant possession.
  2. When you can break. Some leases allow a break on one fixed date. Others allow it at any time on a set period of notice.
  3. What conditions apply. Some break clauses require only a valid notice. Others impose additional conditions on the party exercising the break. Check what must be done and when.

Start with the wording of the signed lease and any documents that vary it, rather than relying on what was discussed during negotiations. 

winston-solicitors-break-clause-in-commercial-leases

What Conditions Does a Break Clause Usually Carry?

The three conditions that cause most break disputes are vacant possession, payment of sums due and compliance with lease covenants. The wording of your lease determines what is required and by when. Do not assume that a missed deadline can be put right afterwards.

What does "vacant possession" mean for a break clause?

Vacant possession generally means the property is free of people, free of the tenant's belongings and free of anyone else's legal rights to occupy.  It is an inoccuous term though and can have serious consequences for a break right.  People or belongings left behind can prevent this. Leaving furniture, stock, partitioning or even rubbish,  can be enough to fetter the break. Check the lease carefully before deciding what to remove and what to leave. 

Does all the rent have to be paid before the break date?

Check exactly which payments the break clause requires and when the payment must be made. Depending on the wording, these may include rent, If payment of rent is a pre-condition to the break and rent is payable quarterly in advance, do not assume that you can pay only up to the break date. In Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2015] UKSC 72, the Supreme Court refused to imply a term requiring the landlord to refund rent paid in advance for the period after the break date. Unless your lease provides for a refund, assume any rent you pay for the period after the break date will not be returned. 

What does compliance with the lease covenants require?

A condition requiring full compliance with the tenant's covenants can put the break at risk even where a breach appears minor. Wording such as "material compliance" or "substantial compliance" are potentially more forgiving, but still leave room for argument. If repairs or decoration form part of the condition, establish early what work is required and when it must be completed. Do not assume that offering a payment instead will satisfy the condition.

How Much Notice Does a Break Clause Need, and How Is It Served?

The lease sets the notice period. Time limits in break clauses are applied strictly so it is important to work out the date for effective service, taking account of any permitted service methods and deemed-service provisions.. Allow time for delivery and keep evidence of service. Do not leave it until the deadline

Check four points before serving the notice.

  1. The right parties. Check who is entitled to exercise the break and who must receive the notice. A solicitor or other authorised agent can act on a party's behalf. Take particular care after a sale, assignment or group restructuring, including where registration of a transfer is still pending.
  2. The right property and lease. Describe the premises and the lease accurately.
  3. The right date. State the break date the lease allows, worked out from the notice period and any fixed dates in the clause.
  4. The right method. Serve it in a way the lease's notice clause permits, to the address it specifies.

Where the lease does not set out its own rules, section 196 of the Law of Property Act 1925 provides methods of service that count as sufficient. Check whether it applies to the particular notice and how it interacts with the lease. Do not assume that posting a notice is enough: the address, method and timing all matter.

 

Why Does Strict Compliance with a Break Clause Matter So Much?

If the break is ineffective, the lease continues and the tenant remains liable under it. That can mean a significant ongoing commitment to rent, service charge and other obligations, even after moving out.

Shereen Lloyd is Head of Commercial Property at Winston Solicitors. Shereen Lloyd is individually ranked in Chambers UK 2027 for Real Estate in Yorkshire.

What We Do on Break Clauses

  • Read the break clause and the whole lease, including side letters, deeds of variation and licences, to confirm what you must do and when
  • Build a timetable back from the break date, with the notice deadline and every condition on it
  • Liaise with specialist litigators in relation to service of break notices
  • Negotiate a surrender where a break is not available or has been missed

We act for landlords, tenants, operators, investors and lenders, nationally across England and Wales.

Understanding a Break Clause - Frequently Asked Questions

See the below FAQs to learn how to deal with a break clause.

IF there is no break clause, a negotiated surrender is often the most practical route to ending a lease early.  Assigning the lease to a buyer, where the lease allows it, passes the lease on rather than ending it, and you may be asked to guarantee the buyer. Winston Solicitors negotiates surrenders and assignments for tenants across England and Wales. 

Yes, if the lease gives the landlord a break right. However, where the tenancy is protected by Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, exercising that right does not by itself bring the protected tenancy to an end. The landlord must also follow the statutory procedure and contractual and statutory notice requirements need to be considered together. Winston Solicitors can check whether your tenancy is protected and advise on the steps required. 

Not on your own. A valid break notice generally cannot be withdrawn without the other party's agreement, so be sure before you serve it. 

Often, yes, as long as it is served within the period the clause allows and gives at least the notice it requires. Some clauses only allow notice inside a fixed window, so a notice served too early can fail in the same way as one served too late. 

No. This page describes the law of England and Wales. Leases of property in Scotland and Northern Ireland follow their own rules on termination and notices. 

How do I break a commercial lease early if there is no break clause?

If there is no break clause, a negotiated surrender is often the most practical route to ending a lease early.  Assigning the lease to a buyer, where the lease allows it, passes the lease on rather than ending it, and you may be asked to guarantee the buyer. Winston Solicitors negotiates surrenders and assignments for tenants across England and Wales.

Speak to Our Commercial Property Team About a Break Clause

Take advice before serving a break notice, with enough time to address the notice requirements and any conditions. With the lease, any variations and the proposed break date in hand, Winston Solicitors can advise on the steps required and the timetable.

Call 0113 320 5000 or email info@winstonsolicitors.co.uk.

Client feedback

Once again thank you Jeremy Conway. You exceeded my expectations! Your attention to detail and customer service are quite outstanding. 6 out of 5 !
Richard C
Excellent service. Very good at keeping us updated on the progress of the sale, which went through swiftly.
Sirs
Transaction completed in a timely manner and Jeremy kept me up to date throughout the process.
Anonymous
Jeremy Conway is an extemely knowledgable and helpful lawyer who dealt with a complex property purchase for me. He provided a first class service at an affordable price.
Anonymous
Very professional and competent service delivered to tight deadlines.
Jackie
Excellent timely accurate service. Eye for detail, supportive advice ang guidance at all times.
Wendy
Excellent service - great communication and advice
Anonymous
Very pleased with the service
Anonymous

Latest news

Contact Shereen