Skip to main content
Legal news

What is structure?

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
1 min read

Leases often contain repairing obligations by reference to the ‘structure’ of the building in question but what does this mean? In a recent case the Court of Appeal ruled that internal plasterwork forms part of the structure of the building and that any discussion as to the exact nature of the plasterwork is irrelevant. Although the case concerned residential premises, the Court of Appeal’s decision will apply to all structures, including commercial buildings.

The Court of Appeal held that for the purposes of the landlord’s obligation to repair the structure and exterior, the plaster applied to the internal walls and ceilings of a dwelling-house formed part of the structure and was not merely decorative finish.

Most commercial leases will contain a definition of the demised premises and (possibly) a definition of the “structure”. This definition should leave no room for doubt or argument. It is also sensible to ascertain what service charge provisions are imposed on the landlord with regard to the “structure” to avoid unwelcome surprises.

Landlords should not be misled by the concept that a “structure” should be a structural part of a building. As this case has shown, it can extend beyond the minimum structural elements, depending on the context.

Client feedback

Winstons are brilliant, very responsive to messages, professional and patient. Fantastic customer service- face to face and email/telephone. Would 100% recommend!
Lucy
I recently contracted Winston Solicitors to support me in obtaining a grant of probate following the death of a parent. I worked closely with Emily and found her to be supportive, have great communication and be able to navigate the IHT and probate processes very efficiently.
John
Absolutely exceptional service from start to finish. I will definitely be recommending you to others. Michelle was fantastic and eased me through the whole process. I had so many questions as a first time buyer, Michelle answered them all and responded quickly every time. Very happy - August 2025
Kimberley W, Derbyshire
We are greatful for Sam's and her team work. We don't believe buying or selling a house could be made any easier. Thank you! - August 2025
Pawel S, Wakefield
Was recommended by my Financial Advisor and was pleasantly surprised everything was dealt with efficiently and everyone I spoke to were kind courteous and knowledgeable I would have no hesitation in using their services again. - August 2025
J Gilbertson, Pontefract
When Mum needed the system most that she had been paying into all her life she was failed by countless people and departments, assessments not completed, lost files, appointments not kept, delay after delay and on. I had a gut feeling that procedures weren't being followed and began my quest for the truth in her memory. I found James at 'Winston Solicitors' who helped us take on the system and prove that Mum was indeed entitled to CHC Funding. Throughout the case he was relentless in his pursuit to seek out the truth and hold those accountable who failed Mum. He gave us regular updates and discussed every step with us along the way, I cannot recommend him highly enough to anyone who has found themselves in this dreadful position in traumatic times with their loved ones. - August 2025
A Ellis, Manchester
Sam and the team have been great in the sale and purchase of my house. Consistent communication and always on hand to answer any questions.
Ms S
We were really happy with Sidraa, she is polite, calm and professional and would definitely recommend her and Winston’s.
Chris
Contact Jonathan