Should the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme reject claims from victims with criminal convictions?  | Winston Solicitors Skip to main content
16716714_cica-unfair-compensation-rejection.jpg
Legal news

Should the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme reject claims from victims with criminal convictions? 

Heidi Stewart Heidi Stewart
3 min read

Should the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme reject claims from victims of crime who have convictions? Well, it does. There is a full spectrum of opinion on whether this is right and fair or not. 

The Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) which administers the government compensation scheme say that awards are not intended to fully compensate victims for what they have lost; the awards are instead society’s way of recognising that a person has suffered because of a violent crime. 

Are all victims of crime treated the same?

If society wants to recognise victims’ suffering, why are we not recognising all victims? Why are some victims more deserving than others? 

The CICA says that if a person has an unspent criminal conviction, whether it be of a violent nature or a simple driving offence, then a claim can be rejected in full. This is disproportionate. A person may have suffered considerable trauma and harm, from a serious assault, or period of sexual abuse, and be denied any compensation at all due to having a driving fine. 

It is easy to find examples where the rule does not seem fair. Consider the ex-offender who gets out of prison and is attacked by a member of his former gang while he is trying to turn his life around and move forward. Or a case of childhood sexual abuse leading to mental health struggles in adult life that can frequently result in links with petty crime such as public order offences. Experience has shown us how a victim of abuse came away with a conviction for a public order offence after a suicide attempt due to the psychological trauma of the abuse. These applications are frequently rejected by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority.

The argument for not awarding compensation to victims with a criminal record is that the scheme is awarding public money and therefore it reflects society’s and government’s wish to penalise convicted offenders. The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 spells out the lengths of time different criminal convictions take to clear off an offender’s record; or to become “Spent”. Society says that until your conviction is “spent” we will continue to treat you differently to others; you must declare your convictions when applying for certain jobs, and they can result in your compensation claim being rejected. 

Should victims with unspent criminal convictions have their claims for compensation rejected under the Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme?  Yes. No. Maybe. Sometimes. 

Finding a compromise 

Surely the solution is to offer a middle ground; an option where the nature of the offence (not just the sentence) is taken into account and considered alongside the nature of the crime which they have been a victim of. Compensation claims could be considered on a case-by-case basis and the victim making the claim could be considered as a whole person, not just a set of statistics. 

If you have an enquiry about a Criminal Injuries Compensation Scheme claim you can contact a member of our team at Winston Solicitors on 0113 320 5000. We can help you work out whether your previous conviction is spent or not and advise you on how and when it is best to make a claim. 
 

Client feedback

Very good service I got from Winston solicitors, they gave me the best service possible.
Kenneth
Brilliant solicitors very professional from the first phone call they listened and cared and saw my complaint through to the end with me receiving the full compensation amount in my case ,would recommend Winston solicitors for all matters ..
Roy
Excellent service would definitely recommend.
Keith
I highly recommend Winston Solicitors especially Heidi Stewart when it comes to getting a compensation claim. I was nervous at first but Heidi was very reassuring supportive as well as professional. She kept me up to date and explained everything,so I knew what was going on from start to finish. Best compensation no win no fee solicitors,as their commission is exceptionally reasonable as well. I trust them 100% to get the job done right and they always put the clients best interests first!
Gayle
They were very good at keeping me up to date and letting me know the progress of my claim
Charley
I had a great experience with Winston Solicitors. They were professional, responsive, and guided me through the entire process with ease. I felt supported and informed at every step, and I’m very pleased with the outcome. I highly recommend their services to anyone in need of legal assistance!
Rochelle
Excellent communication and organised in resolving issue.
Anonymous
Good solicitor
Mahdi
Contact Heidi