Skip to main content
Legal news

Tribunal rules dinner lady unfairly dismissed

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

A tribunal has ruled that a school dinner lady was unfairly dismissed after she told a couple their seven-year-old daughter had been bullied.

Carol Hill was working at Great Tey Primary School in Essex when she witnessed Chloe David, tied to a fence and being whipped with a skipping rope by four boys. The school’s head teacher wrote to Chloe’s parents after the incident but only referred to Chloe suffering a minor injury with a skipping rope, not mentioning that she had been bullied.

However, Mrs Hill saw Chloe’s mother at a scout meeting later and told her what she had witnessed. She then gave a written statement to the family which was passed on to the police. When the school found out, she was suspended for breaching pupil confidentiality and was later sacked for telling a local paper about the case.

Mrs Hill said that she had been made a scapegoat and had been sacked as part of a “cover-up”. The head teacher, Deborah Crabb, said that Chloe had been playing a game of “prisoners and guards” which had gone too far and that the boys in question had been dealt with. She said that she had recommended that the school governors dismiss Mrs Hill for gross misconduct because she had discussed the incident out of school.

A remedy hearing will be held on 2 February to determine whether Mrs Hill will get her job back or be granted compensation.

More Winston Solicitors news

Client feedback

My claim was dealt with professionally and honestly. I am very pleased with the successful outcome. Thank you.
Anon
Efficient and friendly service. Would recommend!
Anon, United Kingdom
Stacey was most helpful in my case
Anon, United Kingdom
James' advice was valuable. He has a wealth of knowledge and expertise in this area, and his advice and guidance were much appreciated. I would highly recommend him.
Anon, United Kingdom
We recently worked with Leasa Foster at Winston Solicitors as our solicitor for purchasing our new home, and we couldn’t be happier with the experience. Leasa was incredibly professional, thorough, and proactive throughout the entire process. She kept us informed at every stage, explained everything clearly, and always responded quickly to our questions — no matter how small.Buying a house can be stressful, but Leasa made the whole journey smooth and straightforward. Her attention to detail and calm, reassuring approach gave us complete confidence that we were in safe hands.We are truly grateful for her support and highly recommend Leasa Foster and Winston Solicitors to anyone looking for an efficient and reliable conveyancing solicitor.
Pranjali
Very handy as a local north Leeds firm, no need to travel to Leeds. Understood exactly what we required and prepared the documents carefully and quickly. Kept us informed as to progress throughout. I would recommend them for any private client work.
Michael
Didn’t have a single issue with Keertan, she was lovely and explained the process very clearly. Kept me updated at every stage and was very helpful.
Hope
I recently used Winston to help with the purchase of my new home. From start to finish, the service was excellent. Leads Foster was professional, efficient, and always kept me informed throughout the process. Every question I had was answered promptly, and everything was explained in a way that was easy to understand. The whole transaction went smoothly and on time, with no hidden surprises. I really appreciated the clear communication and friendly approach. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy solicitor.
Pranjali
Contact Jonathan