Skip to main content
Legal news

Widow wants answers following husband’s tragic death

Jonathan Winston Jonathan Winston
2 min read

A Yorkshire woman has said she is determined to hold a hospital to account following her husband’s death three years ago.

Tony Cartwright, aged just 39, was left with severe brain damage after being rushed to hospital when he developed breathing difficulties due to a rare throat complaint. Medical staff at Harrogate Hospital decided to transfer him to specialist care in York but did so without diagnosing epiglottitis, a potentially dangerous condition which leads to the airway narrowing. Before transferring him to York, staff failed to ensure that his airway was secure and Mr Cartwright subsequently stopped breathing for four minutes, suffering the brain damage as a result. He died in hospital 33 days later.

Three doctors involved in caring for Mr Cartwright were investigated for gross negligence as was Harrogate Hospital for corporate manslaughter, however the Crown Prosecution Service decided not to proceed. The General Medical Council also decided against taking action against two of the doctors involved.

The hospital has admitted breaching its duty of care in attempting to move Mr Cartwright when he had breathing difficulties and Debra Cartwright received damages following his death, but she said that she and her family are still waiting to find out what happened in the critical moments before his collapse. She says that she and her son have been left “desolate” by her husband’s death and that there had been a series of failings in his care.

The hospital’s medical director Carl Gray offered profound condolences to the family and apologised for the failures that occurred in his care. He said: “The trust has implemented a number of actions, which have been reported to the coroner, and we must now await the outcome of the inquest.”

Client feedback

Very helpful and promptly anwsers emails as soon as.
Anonymous
Many of my family members have used Winstons Solicitors for their conyancing, over many years. I too have now used them and they did not disappoint. Samantha Robertson-Strong and Paulo Dos Santos were my main persons of contact. They were highly professional and very thorough, whilst maintaining an air of friendliness and approachability throughout. I cannot recommend them highly enough!
Mr T
Monika is extremely trustworthy, professional and experienced. Have very much felt in safe hands during a very difficult and stressful time of my life. Would highly recommend.
Zoe
Good Solicitors, helped couple times. Nice comunicion and people
Tadas
My son recently purchased a property. I had used Winston Solicitors for many years and had no hesitation in recommending them to him. Their service is outstanding; very professional yet friendly and approachable. Samantha is awesome. She always does a thorough job. Paulo, her assistant, has been an absolute pleasure to deal with as well. So a huge thumbs up and many thanks all around! - October 2025
J Thompson, Manchester
This was a stressful (and as it was a property purchase caused by divorce), very emotional. Samantha and Paulo were always very kind and patient. - October 2025
Dawn B, London
I recently used Winston Solicitors for the purchase of my first home and was extremely impressed with the service. My solicitor, Leasa, along with her assistant, Julie, were outstanding throughout the process—thorough, accommodating, and always patient in explaining each step clearly. They made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable, always going above and beyond to support me. I truly appreciated their professionalism and personal approach, and I would not hesitate to recommend Winston Solicitors to anyone - I cannot thank you all enough. - September 2025
A Woods, Ryton
Professional & thorough throughout conveyancing process. Efficient communication & timely updates from Amr & Joe. Would not hesitate to use their services again. Highly recommend. - September 2025 
Elizabeth M, Leeds
Contact Jonathan